Re: [PATCH] mm/vma: restore VMA iterator on full-range merge failure

From: shao.mingyin

Date: Sat Nov 14 2026 - 16:15:44 EST


Gregory,

Thank you for the candid reply, and for taking the time to write it. I
appreciate that you explained the problem instead of just dismissing the
submission.

You are right about the triage cost. I had been treating an LLM-assisted
patch that gets applied as the measure of a useful contribution, and I
did not weigh the review time that every submission takes from
maintainers -- including the ones that are ultimately rejected. The VMA
iterator patch in this thread was exactly that kind of report: I could
show an internal invariant but not a user-visible effect, and the cost of
reading it was still real. I have withdrawn it.

I will change how I work before sending anything else. I will not submit
a patch until I can state a reachable trigger and a user-visible effect.
If I cannot establish that a report is worth your time, I will not send
it.

Thank you again for the honesty and the guidance. I will take it with me.

Thanks,
Shao