Re: General Discussion about GPLness
From: Bernd Petrovitsch
Date: Sun Feb 23 2020 - 19:43:10 EST
On 23/02/2020 21:47, Stephan von Krawczynski wrote:
> I do understand why you cannot enter a discussion with your real name, as most
I ignore folks who don't use their real name - this is since Usenet
times an indication for a troll ...
> of your input is of zero quality - and below.
> But our story is
> about kernel modules, something everybody is free to write and publish, with a
... publish implicitly with a GPLv2 or compatible license ...
> defined and open interface for interaction. No kernel code is modified in that
And that's a point which is completely wrong: the only *defined*
interface of the kernel is sys-calls, /proc and similar. And all of this
is from user-space to kernel-space and back.
There is no (and never was) a "defined interface" within the kernel
(inter-operating in kernel space) in any direction simply because the
kernel-internal (infra)structure changes more or less constantly - some
may call that evolution;-)
And I don't get what an "open interface" here couls seriously mean. You
surely don't want to call the list of the GPL_EXPORTed C functions
(which may change from one kernel version to the next) an "open
interface" (whatever that should suggest).
At most the list of GPL_EXPORTed C functions is a de-facto interface and
that may change from one git-commit to the next.
> sense. But you fail to understand that.
> Hopefully others here do. I do not expect them to stand up and jump into a
> discussion where you are a part of. But I hope people start to think about it
And you are barking up the wrong tree. The discussion has to happen in
the ZFS-world so that they fix their license if they want to interface
with any GPL software (without sys-calls etc. in between - WTF it works
via FUSE) like they seen to do now.
And no, I'm not a lawyer so I won't comment more on the law-aspects -
the above is my short summary of discussions hereover about license
clashes etc. over the last decades ...
[ Full quote deleted - pls do not top-post]
Bernd Petrovitsch Email : bernd@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
LUGA : http://www.luga.at