Re: [PATCH v2 3/4] spi: spi-geni-qcom: Don't try to set CS if an xfer is pending

[Doug Anderson]

Hi,

On Wed, Dec 16, 2020 at 8:29 PM Stephen Boyd <swboyd@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>
> > The SPI core in general assumes that setting chip select is a simple
> > operation that doesn't fail.  Yet another reason to just reconfigure
> > the chip select line as GPIOs.
>
> BTW, we could peek at the irq bit for the CS change and ignore the irq
> handler entirely. That would be one way to make sure the cs change went
> through, and would avoid an irq delay/scheduling problem for this simple
> operation. Maybe using the irq path is worse in general here?

Yes, when I was in my SPI optimization phase I actually coded this up
and thought about it.  It can be made to work and is probably
marginally faster at the expense of more cpu cycles to poll the
interrupt line.  I also don't think it fixes this issue nor does it
simplify things...  :(

1. If there are already commands pending we still have to do something
about them.  Said another way: there's not a separate channel just for
setting the chip select, so if the single command channel is gummed up
then using polling mode to handle the chip select won't really un-gum
it up.

2. In order to use polling mode to set the chip select we have to do
_something_ to temporarily disable our interrupt handler.  If we don't
do that then the interrupt handler will fire for the "DONE" when we
send the chip select command.


If we wanted to truly make this driver super robust against ridiculous
interrupt latencies then, presumably, we could handle the SPI timeout
ourselves but before timing out we could check to see if the
interrupts were pending.  Then we could disable our interrupts,
synchronize our interrupt handler, handle the interrupt directly, and
then re-enable interrupts.  If we did this then transfers could
continue to eek their way through even if interrupts were completely
blocked.  IMO, it's not worth it.  I'm satisfied with not crashing and
not getting the state machine too out-of-whack.

-Doug