Re: [PATCH 09/13] tools/nolibc: sys_poll: riscv: use __NR_ppoll_time64 for rv32

[Zhangjin Wu]

Hi, Arnd, Thomas, Willy

> On Fri, May 26, 2023, at 09:15, Thomas Wei=C3=9Fschuh wrote:
> > On 2023-05-25 01:57:24+0800, Zhangjin Wu wrote:
> >> 
> >> +/* needed by time64 syscalls */
> >> +struct timespec64 {
> >> +	time64_t	tv_sec;		/* seconds */
> >> +	long		tv_nsec;	/* nanoseconds */
> >> +};
> >
> > A question to you and Willy, as it's also done the same for other types:
> >
> > What is the advantage of custom definitions over using the one from the
> > kernel (maybe via a typedef).
> >
> > From linux/time_types.h:
> >
> > struct __kernel_timespec {
> > 	__kernel_time64_t tv_set;
> > 	long long tv_nsec;
> > };
> 
> I agree the __kernel_* types are what we should be using when
> interacting with system calls directly, that is definitely what
> they are intended for.
> 
> I would go further here and completely drop support for 32-bit
> time_t/off_t and derived types in nolibc. Unfortunately, the
> kernel's include/uapi/linux/time.h header still defines the
> old types, this is one of the last remnants the time32 syscalls
> definitions in the kernel headers, and this already conflicts
> with the glibc and musl definitions, so anything that includes
> this header is broken on real systems. I think it makes most
> sense for nolibc to just use the linux/time_types.h header
> instead and use something like
> 
> #define timespec   __kernel_timespec
> #define itimerspec __kernel_itimerspec
> typedef __kernel_time64_t time_t;
> /* timeval is only provided for users, not compatible with syscalls */
> struct timeval { __kernel_time64_t tv_sec; __s64 tv_nsec; };
> 
> so we can drop all the fallbacks for old 32-bit targets. This
> also allows running with CONFIG_COMPAT_32BIT_TIME disabled.

Just a status update ...

I'm working on the pure time64 and 64bit off_t syscalls support, it almost
worked (tested on rv32/64, arm32/64), thanks very much for your suggestions.

It includes:

* Based on linux/types.h and
    * Use 64bit off_t
    * Use 64bit time_t
    * the new std.h looks like this

    typedef uint32_t __kernel_dev_t;
    
    typedef __kernel_dev_t          dev_t;
    typedef __kernel_ulong_t        ino_t;
    typedef __kernel_mode_t         mode_t;
    typedef __kernel_pid_t          pid_t;
    typedef __kernel_uid32_t        uid_t;
    typedef __kernel_gid32_t        gid_t;
    typedef __kernel_loff_t         off_t;
    typedef __kernel_time64_t       time_t;
    typedef uint32_t                nlink_t;
    typedef uint64_t                blksize_t;
    typedef uint64_t                blkcnt_t;

* Use __kernel_timespec as timespec
* Use 64bit time_t based struct timeval
    * Disable gettimeofday syscall completely for 32bit platforms
        * And disable the gettimeofday_bad1/2 test case too
    * Remove the oldselect and newslect path completely
    * The new types.h looks this:

    /* always use time64 structs in user-space even on 32bit platforms */
    #define timespec __kernel_timespec
    #define itimerspec __kernel_itimerspec

    /* timeval is only provided for users, not compatible with syscalls */
    struct __timeval64 {
    	__kernel_time64_t tv_sec;	/* seconds */
    	__s64 tv_usec;			/* microseconds */
    };
    /* override the 32bit version of struct timeval in linux/time.h */
    #define timeval __timeval64

    /* itimerval is only provided for users, not compatible with syscalls */
    struct __itimerval64 {
    	struct __timeval64 it_interval;	/* timer interval */
    	struct __timeval64 it_value;	/* current value */
    };
    /* override the 32bit version of struct itimerval in linux/time.h */
    #define itimerval __itimerval64

* Use __NR_*time64 for all 32bit platforms
* Use __NR_pselect6/ppoll/clock_gettime only for 64bit platforms
* New sizeof tests added to verify off_t, time_t, timespec, itimerspec...

   	CASE_TEST(sizeof_time_t);           EXPECT_EQ(1, 8,   sizeof(time_t)); break;
    	CASE_TEST(sizeof_timespec);         EXPECT_EQ(1, 16,  sizeof(struct timespec)); break;
    #ifdef NOLIBC
    	CASE_TEST(sizeof_itimerspec);       EXPECT_EQ(1, 32,  sizeof(struct itimerspec)); break;
    #endif
    	CASE_TEST(sizeof_timeval);          EXPECT_EQ(1, 16,  sizeof(struct timeval)); break;
    	CASE_TEST(sizeof_itimerval);        EXPECT_EQ(1, 32,  sizeof(struct itimerval)); break;
    	CASE_TEST(sizeof_off_t);            EXPECT_EQ(1, 8,   sizeof(off_t)); break;


@Arnd, the above timeval/itimerval definitions are used to override the ones
from linux/time.h to avoid such error:

    error: redefinition of ‘struct timeval’

    nolibc/sysroot/riscv/include/types.h:225:8: error: redefinition of ‘struct timeval’
      225 | struct timeval {
          |        ^~~~~~~
    In file included from nolibc/sysroot/riscv/include/types.h:11,
                     from nolibc/sysroot/riscv/include/nolibc.h:98,
                     from nolibc/sysroot/riscv/include/errno.h:26,
                     from nolibc/sysroot/riscv/include/stdio.h:14,
                     from tools/testing/selftests/nolibc/nolibc-test.c:12:
    nolibc/sysroot/riscv/include/linux/time.h:16:8: note: originally defined here
       16 | struct timeval {

@Arnd, As you commented in another reply, is it time for us to update
include/uapi/linux/time.h together and let it provide time64 timeval/itimerval
instead of the old ones? perhaps some libc's are still using them.

Or perhaps we can add a switch like __ARCH_WANT_TIME32_SYSCALLS, add a
__ARCH_WANT_TIME32_STRUCTS and simply bind it with __ARCH_WANT_TIME32_SYSCALLS?

About the above ugly override code, What's your suggestion in v2? ;-)

Best regards,
Zhangjin

> 
>      Arnd