Re: Questions about logic_pio

[Wei Xu]

Hi Jiaxun,

On 2020/2/19 21:58, Jiaxun Yang wrote:
> Hi there,
> 
> Logic PIO gives us a way to make indirect PIO access, however,
> the way it handles direct (MMIO) I/O access confused me.
> 
> I was trying to create a PCI controller Driver and noticed that I/O range parsed
> from DeviceTree will be added to the Logic PIO range by logic_pio_register_range. 
> And than PCI subsystem will use the ioport obtained from `logic_pio_trans_cpuaddr`
> to allocate resources for the host bridge. In my case, the range added to the logic pio
>  was set as hw_start 0x4000, size 0x4000. Later, `logic_pio_trans_cpuaddr` called
> by `pci_address_to_pio` gives a ioport of 0x0, which is totally wrong.
> 
> After dig into logic pio logic, I found that logic pio is trying to "allocate" an io_start
> for MMIO ranges, the allocation starts from 0x0. And later the io_start is used to calculate
> cpu_address.  In my opinion, for direct MMIO access, logic_pio address should always
> equal to hw address, because there is no way to translate address from logic pio address
> to actual hw address in {in,out}{b,sb,w,sb,l,sl} operations.
> 
> How this mechanism intends to work? What is the reason that we are trying to
> allocate a io_start for MMIO rather than take their hw_start ioport directly?
> 
> Thanks. 

Corrected John's mail address.
Maybe he can help.

Best Regards,
Wei

> 
> --
> Jiaxun Yang
> 
> 
> 
> .
>